Aug 05, 2016 valkyrie is a 2008 historic thriller based around one of the most successful attempts to assassinate adolf hitler, but how accurate is it. Historical accuracy of the film valkyrie starring tom. Shouldnt the historical accuracy be moved up to right after the plot section. Director bryan singer, screenplay writers christopher mcquarrie and nathan alexander, and lead actor tom cruise have utilized the july 20. Hopefully this video will cover the basics please like.
Valkyrie is a 2008 world war ii film depicting the 20 july plot by high ranking german officers to kill adolf hitler. What is the historical accuracy of the film valkyrie. The true story of operation finale history smithsonian. Please expound on the historical accuracycharacter issues. Did hitler and the rest of the nazi elite really get blown.
Imdb page valkyrie 2008 i know the basic points are accurate, the fact that there was an assassination attempt on hitlers life, but im wondering about specifics and how close the movie was to real life. Apr 18, 2009 how historically accurate is the film valkyrie. Historical accuracy of the tom cruise movie valkrye. I wondered, isnt taking over the radio station and the main telephone switchboard one of the first things they. It makes the leader of the conspiracy into someone the audience is supposed to identify with, which is problematic. The story recounts, with suitable historical accuracy, one of the attempts on hitlers life. Some had the power to cause the death of the warriors they did not favor. Wondering if anybody has seen the movie, and im not going to say much about it so i dont ruin if for those who are planning on seeing it in the future. Inglourious basterds titular unit consists of jewishamerican soldiers, a decision that greatly benefits the films commercial viability with pitt leading the way as an alist american celebrity. Imdb always attaches a release year to all future films on the site, despite no announcement to support it. May 29, 2009 peter hoffmann, professor of history at mcgill university and a leading authority on the german resistance, was a consultant for the filmmakers. Director bryan singer, screenplay writers christopher mcquarrie and nathan alexander, and lead actor tom cruise have utilized the july 20, 1944, assassination attempt on hitler as the basis for a story that has more to do with. Introduction valkyrie is a 2008 american historical thriller film set in nazi germany during world war ii.
The plot that came closest to succeeding was project valkyrie, which was the subject of the 2010 film valkyrie. The announcement nearly two years ago, that tom cruise was to star in a hollywood production on the failed july 1944 bomb plot against hitler produced widespread derision. The bomb, however, fails to detonate and tresckow safely retrieves it to. Is valkyrie movie 2008 historically accurate and did it really. Valkyrie is a throwback to hollywood period pieces like where eagles dare, in which obvious actions take precedence over historical accuracy. The paper provides a description of the actual events. The conspirator the facts secretary of war edwin stanton was out attending a union victory celebration the night of the assassination. Apr 28, 2016 valkyrie is surprisingly accurate, but in its tone, it misses the mark entirely. The film is true to most of the facts of the plot, but fails to convey any sense of the catastrophic moral and political vortex into which germans. Download 7page thesis on historical accuracy of the tom cruise movie valkrye 2020. Like that other hitler epic, valkyrie is amazingly accurate. The debatable importance of historical accuracy in period. The movie covers the entire operation, from locating klement and confirming his true identity, through his capture, 11day interrogation, return flight to israel, and the opening of the trial.
With tom cruise, bill nighy, carice van houten, kenneth branagh. Only in american cinema would this ever be deemed a good thing. Released in 2008, directed by bryan singer, and starring tom cruise, valkyrie chronicles the 1944 assassination attempt against hitler, in which a significant number of upperranking german military officers participated. An extraordinarily brave soldier and a charismatic leader, his attempt to kill hitler on 20 july at the nazi leader. A significant strength valkyrie has in terms of historic accuracy is the precision of.
Valkyrie, in norse mythology, any of a group of maidens who served the god odin and were sent by him to the battlefields to choose the slain who were worthy of a place in valhalla. In the 1940s champagne was drunk from coupes or champagne saucers which are wide and shallow, much like margarita or daiquiri glasses. I dont say this to imply the film itself is historically. As far as the accuracy, the movie is reminiscent of downfall and is an excellent companion to it.
As with any hollywood rendition of a true story, the screenwriters and filmmakers feel they must. The film valkyrie is the most popularised interpretation of the july 20th 1944 bomb plot. Download 7page research paper on historical accuracy of the film valkyrie starring tom cruise 2020. A significant strength valkyrie has in show more content both in the movie and in history, the conspirators planned to use this document after killing hitler to manipulate the reserve army into removing the power of the ss, gestapo, and sd. Valkyrie is a 2008 american historical thriller film set in nazi germany during world war ii. The film incorporated many aspects that are historically accurate, despite a number of minor historical flaws.
Even before the war there were attempts on his life and this did not stop once he became the fuhrer hitler owed. Directed by bryan singer the usual suspects, superman returns, valkyrie turns a lesserknown historical footnote into a gripping, wellexecuted thriller. Last night i was flipping channels and saw a few minutes of history channel quazipromo of valkyrie. A significant strength valkyrie has in terms of historic accuracy is the precision of the plot and the plot twists. In the story, the basterds rescue a german, hugo stiglitz til schweiger, who killed thirteen gestapo officers. As this is a dramatisation rather than a documentary, some of these would have been deliberate choices by the writers and director for artistic effect. Facts this page was created to point out some the historical inaccuracies of robert redfords film the conspirator, released april 2011.
What are some examples of historical inaccuracies in valkyrie. Characters in the movie were drinking champagne from tall slender flutes. Mar 22, 2012 the july 20, 1944 plot to kill hitler how accurate was valkyrie, the 2008 movie. Valkyrie is a meticulous thriller based on a largescale conspiracy within the german army to assassinate hitler, leading to a failed bombing attempt on july 20, 1944. Aug 28, 2018 the movie covers the entire operation, from locating klement and confirming his true identity, through his capture, 11day interrogation, return flight to israel, and the opening of the trial. Valkyrie is, in essence, a thriller more than it is a war movie, and its a damn good one at that. The director, bryan singer, sought to accurately represent history by using the facts of the plot with effectiveness. How historically accurate was the 2008 movie valkyrie. Cruise is a hollywood version of actual historical events. Valkyrie is a 2008 thriller film directed and coproduced by bryan singer and written by christopher mcquarrie and nathan alexander. As shown in the move, he was able to button his shirt and jacket by himself and also able to prime the bomb despite his injuries. A quick check on the imdb goofs page for the movie shows a number of anachronisms and other inaccuracies the factual errors section is quite long. The 20 july 1944 plot to kill hitler and valkyrie, the movie. In a companion movie clip, they showed cruise as col.
The film is designed to mean something entirely different to americans than it does to us. The paper concludes that the historical accuracy of the film is not as important as the actual making and viewing of the film. But such a movie would not contain the immaculate hero which tom cruise presents to us. Cruise is surrounded by a terrific cast including kenneth branagh, terrence stamp, and bill nighy as his coconspirators, while oscar nominee tom wilkinson plays a military commander. The historical accuracy of the film can be demonstrated by showing its plot, setting and characters.
Valkyrie is a 2008 historic thriller based around one of the most successful attempts to assassinate adolf hitler, but how accurate is it. Hoffmann spoke of the films accuracy, valkyrie gives a fundamentally accurate portrait of stauffenberg and his coconspirators. The july 20, 1944 plot to kill hitler how accurate was valkyrie, the 2008 movie. A dramatization of the july 20, 1944 assassination and political coup plot by desperate renegade german army officers against adolf hitler during world war ii. The gestapo investigated the 20 july plot thoroughly, so filmmakers had access to much documentation as they integrated the historical account with hollywood factors in producing valkyrie. Tom cruise and the plot to kill hitler film the guardian. On 20 july 1944, a german colonel left a bomb in the fuhrers office. Valkyrie and accuracy last night i was flipping channels and saw a few minutes of history channel quazipromo of valkyrie. O n seeing the movie, valkyrie, about the 20 july plot to kill hitler, i was struck by the plotters apparent failure to secure all communications. An analysis of the historical accuracy of the movie valkyrie, directed by bryan singer. In green zone, the new iraq war thriller starring matt damon, cooked up wmd intelligence, secretive cia leaks and wardrumming conspiracies are rampant. Valkyrie werd genomineerd voor onder meer zeven saturn awards.
Just how historically accurate was tom cruises valkyrie. Historical accuracy in terms of how many ridiculous liberties are taken with history, inglourious basterds is the clear winner here, too. Charting the reallife events that saw a number of highranking nazi officers attempt to overthrow hitler, the movie stars tom cruise as col. Valkyrie, bryan singers film about the plot to assassinate adolf hitler, is out now on dvd and bluray. The segment i saw was touting what care the producers went to in regards to authenticity. The existing variety citations do not make any mention of the release date, so unless there is a followup citation, the release date has yet to be announced. An extraordinarily brave soldier and a charismatic leader, his attempt to kill hitler on 20 july at. Berkel, bill nighy, tom cruise, terence stamp, david schofield. Mar 15, 2010 in green zone, the new iraq war thriller starring matt damon, cooked up wmd intelligence, secretive cia leaks and wardrumming conspiracies are rampant. Intimidated by history if hes shooting for an oscar with valkyrie, cruise is going to miss the target. I knew the history and exactly how it turned out, but this film still kept me on the edge of my seat throughout.
Though there had been many celebrations in washington city over. The film is set in nazi germany during world war ii and depicts the 20 july plot in 1944 by german army officers to assassinate adolf hitler and to use the operation valkyrie national emergency plan to take. The debatable importance of historical accuracy in period films. Peter hoffmann, professor of history at mcgill university and a leading authority on the german resistance, was a consultant for the filmmakers. And therein lies the problem with films about true life tales. There are details which must be counted as liberties. Make no mistake, this is hardly a film hell bent on historical accuracy. Valkyrie is surprisingly accurate, but in its tone, it misses the mark entirely. Valkyrie is a 2008 historic thriller based around one of the most. Sep 12, 2015 as far as the accuracy, the movie is reminiscent of downfall and is an excellent companion to it. Shooting scenes at night was difficult because presenting historical accuracy of the era required.
Terry press, a marketing consultant with the studio, said that valkyrie had been wrongly labeled as the tom cruise eyepatch movie. Valkyrie is a 2008 thriller film directed and coproduced by bryan singer and written by. Historical accuracy of movie valkyrie if i were awarding thumbs up for the historical. Valkyrie directed by bryan singer certificate 12a, 2008. Historical accuracy of the film valkyrie starring tom cruise. Im not a uniform junkie, but wasnt the red stripe reserved for. The film depicts the 20 july plot in 1944 by german army officers to assassinate adolf hitler and to use the operation valkyrie national emergency plan to take control of the country valkyrie film. Based on a true story, the film recounts a daring coup that attempted to assassinate hitler and. This movie contains a good number of established stars in key roles, including kenneth branagh, bill nighy, tom wilkinson, thomas kretschmann, terence stamp, and eddie izzard. The plot was equal parts desperation due to germanys looming defeat in the war and genuine disgust with nazi.
Valkyrie is a compelling and thrilling historical drama about a fascinating chapter in history. Valkyrie is a thriller, but it is not a historical film. Singer is a talented director, but its time for him to find his own voice again. The internet movie database does not qualify as a source for the films release date.
I had ten times more enjoyment in those 2 minutes than in the first half hour of the movie. These foreboders of war rode to the battlefield on horses, wearing helmets and shields. A thriller, but not a historical film world socialist web site. Valkyrie, also spelled walkyrie, old norse valkyrja chooser of the slain, in norse mythology, any of a group of maidens who served the god odin and were sent by him to the battlefields to choose the slain who were worthy of a place in valhalla.
115 500 1533 375 742 1375 137 1075 982 594 1438 383 1629 60 986 752 1463 1005 49 1169 749 572 1531 975 1594 1421 586 1154 819 959 1420 602 1617 705 810 810 296 274 1120 329 1332 1030 192 514 1297